Tuesday, July 29, 2008
All Rise
Not since school days , do I remember standing up when a teacher walked into a lecture hall; surely, not during my two years at Ruia, not the five years at GS and of course not after joining radiology.
May be in those yesteryears we were more concerned with truly having respect than just showing it.
But, these are different times…
When the Dean walks in for a meeting, most faculty and Chiefs stand up and this percolates all the way down along the line to our students. But, I steadfastly refuse to - even ignoring Nalini’s stern disapproving glance .. not because I do not respect Deans, but simply because, I do not see any reason to demonstrate that publicly. The only GSites who seem to blissfully unaware of the hierarchy are the native-bread, dyed in the wool, GSite packs of dogs. They seem respect only the hands that feed them and can even be trained to bark loudly and run after the Dean’s (new) car..
What? Do you want GS to got to the dogs?... – literally- should they set the tone for behaviour- they better stand to attention with heads bowed in veneration!
I do not think so, I do not think, standing up when some one senior walks in is a true show of respect.. may be a show, but not necessarily a true show… may be respect, but, not necessarily true respect. And, I should know .. what with the under-the-breath expletives that are uttered even as my colleagues stand to a senior faculty or administrator.
So, I find it exasperating when people stand up when I walk into our conference room for a lecture, or into the lecture theater for the occasional UG lecture I give. Thank God, they do not follow it up with a “Good Morning teacher…”
Students and residents standing up….. may be… just about may be OK, but what is most embarrassing is this.. You see, we have these inter-departmental clinical meetings several times a week. We have senior faculty from various departments coming into our conference room to discuss cases and teach. And, it embarrasses me no end, when they too stand up when I enter the room… and then their poor residents have no option but to follow suit..
Why do I loath this so much.. why do I not feel good when another professor calls me “Sir” and stands up in 'respect' for me. About senior faculty I do not know. No amount of persuasion seems to work; whereas some have changed to “Dr. Ravi” or “Ravi” over the years, others whom I consider great colleagues and respect a lot – some of them the finest faculty and we have on the campus today - insist and continue to call me “Sir”. One particular one is very candid and says says "I do not care what you say Sir, but, I will continue to call you 'Sir', Sir". So, after a while I leave these folks alone and admire their honesty and candidness at what they feel, say and do.
But what about the kids, the UG and PG ones?
I would like to believe that they really respect their teachers,, I would like to believe that their teachers live up to their expectations and deserve the veneration that the students seem to shower on them; but sometimes, I wonder if all that they do is just lip … err leg service as they “All Rise”
I do not know if you have noticed it lately, but the new generation of kids has no qualms about rushing into lifts, or sit all across the steps of the college stairs or walk 5 across along our long corridors blissfully ignorant of the inconvenience that they are causing others – junior or senior. I do not know about you, I have but rarely seen these kids, make way for others or for that matter even sick patients. Surely there may be exceptions to this.. but that is not “as a rule” as it ought to be. And , of course, it was not like this during out times. May be we did not stand up when professors walked into our classes, but we never hogged the staircases, the corridors or the lifts.
But as I never tire of saying this.. I am sure it is not the fault of the kids.. they have never been taught otherwise. They have never been told that true respect is respect for any fellow human being whether it is a poor patient in tattered closes or the Dean in his starched white apron. It is important to see who really needs respect. For, making way for a sick patient, or a ward-boy with a heavy load or a patient on a wheel chair is the true demonstration of caring, courtesy and hence respect for all fellow human beings , A way to show that we truly care…
So, show true respect by making way for a patient for the elevator, a trolley on the corridor or a ward boy with a heavy load. Let’s respect people for what they are rather than for what the signages outsides their offices or the name tags on the apron pockets proclaim them to be….
Let’s “All Rise” to people for what they are rather than to their titles that denote their “importance.”
So the next time any one stands up when I enter our conference room, he/she is doing it at his/her own risk of having to continue to stand.. for you will never again hear a “Please be seated" from me.
(This essay is inspired by Subroto Bagchi’s “The Missing I”
Sunday, March 16, 2008
Back to School
The date was
The idea was mooted by a GSite – naturally (not I, but a batch mate of mine) who modelled it on the now traditional silver jubilee (our batch had in 1996) and golden jubilee (will I be around then?) alumni get-togethers of our college.
It seemed an impossible task then in September 2007 when the idea was sown - but with cell phones, e mails and internet, a majority could be contacted and about a third attended.
It is difficult for me to describe my emotions as I entered my school today. Had we done a functional MRI on my brain then, you would have seen my temporal lobes on fire. A rush of memories and unique emotions is what I felt – and I said to myself “Why did we not think of this earlier?”
Those of you that have read my previous essays here, probably know that I always considered my school days as the best days of my life so far – well ahead of my GS career and the reason for that was not just my great school friends and those friendships devoid of politics but the almost “romantic” respect that I had for some of my teachers.
So, it was natural that when I saw my maths teacher enter school that morning, I rushed out to him to say “Sir, let me have the pleasure of welcoming you first” – not that he would have remembered me but because I was possessed by nostalgia.
Slowly, many other teachers trotted in - some walking straight and briskly, others slowly hopping in; but, all with radiant smiles on their faces.
Friends were a different ball game altogether; the boys from my class - I had no problem recognizing (I made a profound observation that day that madrasis, unlike others do not easily have temporal hair recession (unlike my balding GS classmates in 1996) – you see it is coconut oil we use ! – (may be I should write it up!) . There was a sizable number girls, some like a few boys, having come from outside town - I could not recognize a single one of them. But after brief introductions we back to old days chatting away like animated kids catching up on all that was left out in those 11 years at school (ah!, in our days, boys never talked to girls in school!!).
In vividly memorable moments, the assembled teachers were felicitated by their students and then we had the pièce de résistance – a full 15 min. lecture on Algebra and Geometry by our mathematics teacher – black board, chalk and all…. In his now familiar , inimitable style punctuated by wry humor he enthralled us for those golden moments and the best part – he certified us as being better in maths than we are at school.
I can go on and on with a compilation of the goings on that day - which like a normal school day ended at 4, but that is not point my writing this piece.
You see, that day I was not RR of KEM but Ravi R of SIES, I was not Ravi Sir, but Ravi Student, I was not asking the questions but answering them and then it suddenly dawned on me that there is the other side – the students’ side and when one of teachers in her emotionally chocked voice said – “the teacher student relation ship is eternal”, I couldn’t agree more.
I am so lucky to be surrounded by my students, I am lucky to have them stimulate me, I am lucky that one day, we will meet again and a tottering
And dear kids, these days if you see me a little more considerate and nice to you – you know why – it is “hang over” of the magic of the reunion!!
Now, go and have your own – it will change your life in ways that would have scarce imagined!!
March 2008
Saturday, November 17, 2007
Sorry? No way!
There are cat fights and dog fights.
The only difference is that animal fights do not involve ego. And hence they can settle without much backlash.
Not so easy with humans; not- especially if you a 25 something resident in KEM!!
Resident warfare is nothing new – not to us in Radiology anyway, where we have had to interact with virtually every other department in the hospital.
In my times as resident, it was not warfare – just fights – simply because all residents were GSites, we were mostly from the same batch – most were friends. Even after a heated argument, most times, we were friends again. Not so today. There are major cultural and “ethnic” differences amongst residents, language barriers exist and misunderstanding of what is said, heard and meant is rampant.
So, we no longer have fights – just plain simple warfare.
There are many variations and uncertainties about these resident warfare – the only certain thing is that it will occur with alarming regularity.
It all started with a couple of phone calls (not one, but two) at my home on a lazy Sunday afternoon from a couple of residents from one of the superspeciality units complaining about the “rude and threatening” behaviour from a radiology resident. I listened politely to the outpouring on the phone and as is usual, I said, “We will sort it out tomorrow”.
Tomorrow came.
I have learned from experience, not to open my mouth without listening to both sides… and as happens always, the versions from the radiology side and the “other” side were quite and significantly different – I got a distinct impression that some blatant lies were being let loose. All this is old hat for me, so I did not bother to counter or argue since I have always held that in matters such as these “The truth is always somewhere in between.”
And the exact truth is impossible to ascertain and in my opinion, no energy and time needs to be wasted on this.
As is my won’t, I gave philosophical lecture to the residents from the other department (my own resident must have had enough of this just being a radiology resident)… I thought things would smoothen out. A couple of hours later, the five of us sat to round to put one more “L'affaire des residents” behind us.
The concerned department Chief, each, the two concerned residents from that department, the radiology resident and I sat across.
“I do not want to go into details” , I started off to my resident – “What you said seems to have hurt them”. So I suggest you just say “Sorry” to them, if what you said has hurt them.
The poor radiology resident had no option against my request, which must obviously have been seen as a command.
“I am sorry, if I had hurt you” promptly blurted the radiology resident.. I felt great. The resident had lived up to my expectation and “ideals”
“Now why don’t you say sorry” said the other department chief to his residents.
A few tense, silent moments passed and out came the shocker.
“We do not think we have done anything that we should say sorry for” was the startling response from them
I was aghast, taken aback as this what I had least expected.. From there demeanor, it was clear that there was defiance and no remorse. I saw no pint in pushing the matter further.
I politely thanked my contemporary and along with my resident left the room.
On the way down, I could hear sobs from my resident. That too didn’t shock me – it always ends in sobs and tears.
“I do not want you to feel bad about having to say an unilateral sorry; I said to my resident who was walking along, “In fact, I am proud that my resident has the courage and sensitivity to behave in a civilized manner. That they did not want to say sorry is their problem, It in no way reflects on you.”
With that I left the resident to personal thought and sobs.
On my way home to lunch, it was obvious to me, that the other residents had missed the point of the whole exercise. It was not a matter of who was right or wrong but one of putting things behind with one of the three most important words in English language “Sorry” ( “Thank you” and “Please” being the other two). I was not angry with those residents - not in the least; I felt sorry for them.
For, some day when they are older and lived through the travails of life, seen ups and downs over which they have no apparent controil, have their own 25 year old kids, they will realize how important it is to learn to get along with others, not to let minor issues hurt yourself or that the Newton’s third law is about “mechanics” not human relationships
When dogs bark; you do not bark right back – just walk along and away from them.
It is never too late to learn.
June 2007
Listen
March 2003
As you walk along
The one thing that sets us apart from all other “repairers” is that we deal with human beings.
And these very human beings are the ones that surround us as we walk along the long and stately, but crowded, corridors of our hospital. They are so many of them that we bitterly complain about being besieged by them. But then, give this a thought in one of your leisurely moments. They are there, because they are sick or they are the near and dear ones of those who are sick. I never tire of saying this… they are here not because they want to .., but because they have to.
And then many of us (I, included) walk along these corridors as if we were afraid to look left or right (some even seem to be averse to look up or straight; all the while seeming to admire the tile work on the floor!) and, when we stand on the corridor to exchange words with colleagues, we are careful to avoid those danger spots, where patients are most likely to ask for directions (the place outside radiology is a classic example).
And inside general radiology, on a crowded morning, I see swarms of patients, but no compassion. I see a beleaguered mother trying to console a sick child, standing at the end of what seems to be a never ending queue for a 30 second chest x ray – but none of the radiology staff has thought it fit to push her up forward in the queue. So the mother waits… and the child wails …. and the chaos goes on…nobody seems to care .. or, at least, so it seems.
The reason is not far to seek….
If you see any one in a white coat animatedly giving directions or explaining things to a patient in the corridor, I bet you 100 to 1, it is a first term medical student or student nurse. By the time you are through with your clinical terms .. you have hardened worse than a raw potato frozen in a deep freeze - to a point that nothing seems to move you. Some even say … it better be that way – else you cannot function as a doctor.
Not really……
If one realizes that a greeting softly spoken, a polite “please sit down” or accommodating a patient who turns up late for an appointment or - as you are getting into a lift - “you first”… can make a world of difference to a patient who has been in a cross country race across the four buildings of the hospital or patiently giving directions to a lonely, anxious mother, with a head-injured baby in her arms trying to solve a jig-saw puzzle of reaching Ward 3 from the casualty.
“Who has the time?” says my wife, as she reads over my shoulder, these words appearing haltingly on the monitor screen. In reality, however, it does not take much off our time to spend a helpful few minutes with patients who need us or seem to be lost in the maze of our corridors. I do not know what it does to you .. but a small ‘thank you’ from one such patient makes the day for me.
More than all this, your students and residents who see you doing this are unlikely to turn away a patient asking for directions .. or turn a blind ear to wailing child …a new generation has been taught the first lessons in courtesy we so sorely seem to lack.
July 2002
